How far should scientists be allowed to go in creating things that resemble primitive human brains, hearts, and even human embryos?
That's the question being asked by a group of Harvard scientists who are doing exactly that in their labs. They're using stem cells, genetics and other new biological engineering techniques to create tissues, primitive organs and other living structures that mimic parts of the human body.
Their concern is that they and others doing this type of "synthetic biology" research might be treading into disturbing territory.
"We don't know where this going to go," says John Aach, a lecturer in genetics at Harvard Medical School. "This is just the beginning of this field."
Aach helped write a paper in the journal eLife, published Tuesday, calling for an international effort to establish guidelines for this provocative area of research.
While all this may sound like something out of Frankenstein, the goal is to find new ways to decipher the mysteries of human biology and to discover novel treatments for health problems ranging from infertility to aging.
"We want to understand biology of natural human development and disease and come up with ways of addressing the problems of disease," Aach says. "The more precisely you can make something that is like a tissue or a system of tissues in a dish, the easier it is to experiment on it."
But in the process of conducting their experiments, Aach and his lab colleagues realized scientists might cross disturbing ethical lines.
For example, scientists could create primitive beating hearts and primordial brains.
"How much moral concern should we have for these things? If it has a brain that doesn't look like a human brain, but it operates like one, it could still feel pain," Aach says.
Some scientists have already started creating entities that resemble the very early stages of human embryos. Scientists use different names to describe them. They're sometimes called "embryoids," but Aach's group has dubbed them "SHEEFs" synthetic human entities with embryo-like features.
In some of these experiments, researchers have seen early signs of the formation of the "primitive streak," which is the beginning of a central nervous system and, potentially, the ability to sense pain.
That work raises the prospect that the experiments might violate the 14-day rule, which has been in place for decades to avoid raising too many ethical concerns about experimenting on human embryos. Two weeks into embryonic development is usually when the primitive streak begins to appear.
But Aach and his colleagues argue that the 14-day rule, which is a guideline in the United States and law in some other countries, has become outdated by this latest generation of experiments.
It's based on the predictable, linear development of a normal human embryo. But the new synthetic biology techniques do not necessarily follow that road map.
"The primitive streak was like a stop sign," Aach says. "If you stopped there you would never get a brain. You would never get a heart. You would never get something that would be morally concerning."
"But now with these tissue engineering and stem cell techniques you can simply go around that," Aach says. "You could create something at a point beyond that. It might become sentient."
It's also possible that some day these embryoids could become so much like a normal human embryo that they could actually be used to create a baby.
So, in essence, "you've gone off-road," Aach says. "With these synthetic tissues there's no longer one highway of development. A stop sign is no longer good enough."
The ethical concerns are not just limited to structures that resemble embryos, Aach says.
As a result, he and the co-authors of the report say new guidelines are needed to replace that clear stop sign with something that's more like a guardrail or fence that will keep scientists from inadvertently steering into ethically troubling terrain.
"What we're proposing is, instead of doing stop signs, we get these perimeter fences where there's an agreement that there's an area of concern," Aach says.
For example, scientists, philosophers, bioethicists and others may reach a consensus that "we can't make a brain that will allow it to feel pain" or "we can't make something like a heart but we can make up to it," Aach says, "as long as it doesn't start beating."
Others scientists praised the researchers for raising these tough issues early.
"I absolutely support this," Magdelena Zernicka-Goetz tells Shots in an email; she is doing similar research at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom. "The time is right to begin discussion of these issues in a forum that includes scientists and has a wide representation of society," Zernicka-Goetz says.
Some bioethicists also welcomed a debate about these issues.
"I really have to give them credit for raises these issues proactively," says Insoo Hyun, a Case Western Reserve University bioethicist. "Our current standards for oversight and ethics are not adequate to capture this new area of science."
But it could be difficult to draw the line in some cases, Hyun notes, such as in experiments aimed at developing treatments for pain or those aiming to understanding the heart better.
"Those types of experiments may be exactly the point of why you'd want to create a synthetic entity that does have some kind of pain sensation, or that has some sort of neural network, or has some sort of heart beat, if that's actually the body system you want to study," Hyun says.
And, he says, there may be some experiments people find disturbing on a visceral level.
"Some people may just find that the experiments are just kind of creepy," Hyun says. "There may be some people concerned about scientists taking the research too far, creating entities in the dish that are quasi-human and [that they] de-value life in the process."
Ali Brivanlou, an embryologist at the Rockefeller University who is conducting some of the most advanced work in this area, also says he welcomes a debate. But worried about putting too many limitations on the research.
"We have to dive into this carefully, but I think we really need to move forward," he tells Shots. "I think it's important that we don't somehow let religion or political conviction be a guiding force in this argument. The truth has to come from science."
Originally posted here:
Harvard Scientists Call For Better Rules To Guide Research On 'Embryoids' - Alabama Public Radio
- Woman Who Conceived Twins in Rape Rejects Abortion, Shares How Her 21-Year-Old Twins Saved Her Life - The Epoch Times - October 13th, 2022
- Kid Captain Eli Belser takes the field with Hawkeyes, celebrating two years cancer free - UI The Daily Iowan - September 8th, 2022
- How space technology like the James Webb telescope is improving healthcare on Earth - The National - July 27th, 2022
- How COVID-19, Long COVID, and COVID Vaccines Differ Between Males and Females - CreakyJoints - July 27th, 2022
- Researchers find fabrication of artificial heart for transplant - ThePrint - July 19th, 2022
- Paolo Macchiarini - Wikipedia - July 3rd, 2022
- President Freeman Hrabowski prepares for retirement after turning UMBC into the top producer of Black M.D., Ph.D. graduates - Afro American - July 3rd, 2022
- Women find community in STEM fields at UA - The University of Alabama Crimson White - April 19th, 2022
- Poker Run event planned to benefit twins with rare syndrome - The Andalusia Star-News - Andalusia Star-News - April 6th, 2022
- Dr Borehams Crucible: Mesoblast within months of 3 major trial results, key regulatory decision - Stockhead - July 6th, 2020
- Alabama Stem Cells | Stem Cell TV - September 12th, 2019
- Only Cosmetic Stem Cell Therapy in Alabama - msbmd.com - April 20th, 2019
- Stem Cell Therapy in Houston, TX | National Stem Cell Centers - March 23rd, 2019
- Central Alabama Pain Management Center Established 1993 - March 6th, 2019
- Stem Cell Mobile Alabama 36607 - January 4th, 2019
- Stem Cell Birmingham Alabama 35282 - August 30th, 2018
- USA College of Medicine - University of South Alabama ... - July 24th, 2018
- Researchers find new glioblastoma inhibitor - Patient Daily - August 24th, 2017
- A Chip That Reprograms Cells Helps Healing, At Least In Mice - Alabama Public Radio - August 12th, 2017
- 'Happiness' Explores The Complex Push And Pull Of Human Relationships - Alabama Public Radio - August 12th, 2017
- Hampton Creek to enter clean meat market in 2018: 'We are building a multi-species, multi-product platform' - FoodNavigator-USA.com - June 30th, 2017
- Brain Tumors: Still Devastating, but Treatment Has Come a Long Way - Newswise (press release) - June 20th, 2017
- Walk for "terrible, awful" disease - Timmins Press - June 18th, 2017
- Rare disease hits 2 of family's 4 children - The Ledger - June 18th, 2017
- Hill-Rom Holdings, Inc. (HRC) Reaches $76.89 52-Week High, Biotime (NYSEMKT:BTX) Shorts Increased By 4.64% - UtahHerald.com - June 13th, 2017
- STEM College Students Who Learn by Example May Lack Key Attribute - GoodCall News (blog) - June 13th, 2017
- Wolf Evolution and Settled Science - PLoS Blogs (blog) - June 8th, 2017
- 3D-Printed Patch Mends Hearts - Photonics.com - June 6th, 2017
- When states have strong guns laws, they also have fewer fatal police shootings - Los Angeles Times - May 19th, 2017
- Top graduating senior in 'crazy race to the finish line' | Berkeley News - UC Berkeley - May 9th, 2017
- 3D-printed patch could lead to new treatments for patients after a heart attack - Biotechin.Asia - May 5th, 2017
- Meet Curry Cates: 2017 Big Man on Campus - The Auburn Plainsman - April 28th, 2017
- Andrews Institute Looks Ahead - Inweekly - April 27th, 2017
- UMN research team fixes broken hearts with 3D-printed tissue patch - Minnesota Daily - April 27th, 2017
- Bengals set to hold onto McCarron for at least 1 more year | Sports ... - Newsexaminer - April 27th, 2017
- Andrews Institute Celebrates Ten Years, Looks to Next Ten - WUWF - April 25th, 2017
- Scientists want to help you recover heart attack with a 3d printed patch - Industry Leaders Magazine - April 25th, 2017
- Bengals set to hold onto McCarron for at least 1 more year - WTOP - April 25th, 2017
- Mending broken hearts - The Sydney Morning Herald - April 22nd, 2017
- 3D-printed Patch Can Help Mend a 'Broken' Heart | Technology ... - Technology Networks - April 22nd, 2017
- UAB performs Alabama's first transplant where cadaver liver is 'kept ... - Medical Xpress - April 22nd, 2017
- Heart-healing patch has got the beat - New Atlas - April 20th, 2017
- 3D-printed Patch Can Help Mend a 'Broken' Heart - Technology Networks - April 19th, 2017
- 3D-Printed Patch Can Help Mend a 'Broken' Heart | Lab Manager - Lab Manager | News (press release) (blog) - April 18th, 2017
- 3D-printed patch can help mend a broken heart - UMN News - April 14th, 2017
- Bart Starr returns to Tijuana for stem cells - USA Today - April 10th, 2017
- Pioneering Investigators in Experimental Heart Stem Cell and ... - Newswise (press release) - April 9th, 2017
- The mystique of the invisible: Understanding mental illness - Glens Falls Post-Star - March 27th, 2017
- The Equities Research Analysts' Updated EPS Estimates for March, 20th (AIMT, AMID, AUPH, AVD, BDREF, BPTH ... - Petro Global News 24 - March 23rd, 2017
- Hettinger, ND gets state-of-art new clinic and vets - AG Week - March 21st, 2017
- State-of-art new clinic - and vets - The Dickinson Press - March 19th, 2017
- 3 Women Blinded By Unproven Stem Cell Treatments - Alabama Public Radio - March 16th, 2017
- Hot Biotech Stocks Recap: Nektar Therapeutics (NASDAQ:NKTR), Biostage, Inc. (NASDAQ:BSTG) - The Voice Registrar - March 7th, 2017
- Trump's coal council to drill down on advanced technology - Washington Examiner - March 6th, 2017
- Embryo Experiments Reveal Earliest Human Development, But Stir Ethical Debate - Alabama Public Radio - March 3rd, 2017
- Houston Solar Car featured in IMAX film, Smithsonian - Northeast Mississippi Daily Journal - February 24th, 2017
- News Scan for Feb 20, 2017 - CIDRAP - February 21st, 2017
- On Second Attempt, SpaceX Launches Rocket At NASA's Historic Pad - Alabama Public Radio - February 20th, 2017
- A Liftoff Deferred: SpaceX Mission From NASA's Historic Launch Pad Delayed - Alabama Public Radio - February 19th, 2017
- ECO VIEWS: Advertising is not just for humans - Tuscaloosa News - February 13th, 2017
- ECOViEWS: Advertising is not just for humans - Aiken Standard - February 11th, 2017
- Unsung: Jewel Plummer Cobb - Undark Magazine - February 8th, 2017
- Bart Starr prepares to watch Super Bowl from home as health keeps improving - USA TODAY - February 7th, 2017
- Romero '87 Sees ACLU Donations Soar, Munson *79 to Lead RIT, and More - Princeton Alumni Weekly - February 7th, 2017
- Meet the Team - The University of Alabama at Birmingham - January 26th, 2017
- Tallasee Dog Undergoes Stem Cell Procedure - Alabama News - December 30th, 2016
- Dermal fibroblast - Wikipedia - November 27th, 2016
- Stem Cell Hair Growth Huntsville | Steve Latham Hair ... - September 12th, 2016
- Adult Stem Cell Success - Children of God for Life - April 18th, 2015
- Can cancer vaccines prolong survival? - April 7th, 2015
- Human embryonic stem cells clinical trials - Wikipedia ... - February 19th, 2015
- Christian singer Carman shares testimony of cancer victory - February 2nd, 2015
- Urban Dictionary: stem cell - January 21st, 2015
- Huntsville blood bank to preserve umbilical cord tissues - November 25th, 2014
- CGS : 60 Minutes Exposes Stem Cell Scams Again - November 22nd, 2014
- What Are Stem Cells? (with pictures) - wiseGEEK - November 16th, 2014
- alabama StemCells Therapy StemCells Therapy - October 24th, 2014
- Life Issues Institute - Successes of Adult Stem Cell ... - October 16th, 2014
- A heartbeat away? Hybrid 'patch' could replace transplants - October 1st, 2014
- Huntsville AL Resources - Stem Cells: Get Facts on Uses ... - September 29th, 2014